Skip to content
Kelly
Join the waitlist

NFL player prop history by player

Extra points props in the 2026 season: overs hit 48.1% of decided games against each game's own closing line (38-41-0 over-under-push, 32 players).

Extra points by player (32)

Each player-game is graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart. Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples. A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.

Showing (32) of (32) · Totals · Sorted by Graded, high to low · Compared with every player with 10+ decided games (0)

PlayerPosTeamGradedO-U-POver %Avg vs closeAvg close
Andre SzmytKCLE42-2-050%0.251.5
Brandon AubreyKDAL42-2-050%02.75
Cameron DickerKLAC31-2-033.3%-0.51.5
Chad RylandKARI31-2-033.3%-0.51.83
Chris BoswellKPIT31-2-033.3%-0.832.5
Evan McPhersonKCIN33-0-0100%1.832.83
Jake BatesKDET31-2-033.3%-0.172.83
Jason SandersKNYJ31-2-033.3%-0.831.5
Joey SlyeKTEN33-0-0100%0.831.5
Ka'imi FairbairnKHOU32-1-066.7%0.832.17
Nick FolkK—30-3-00%-0.832.17
Ryan FitzgeraldKCAR30-3-00%-0.832.17
Spencer ShraderKIND31-2-033.3%0.171.5
Trey SmackKGB32-1-066.7%0.832.17
Tyler BassKBUF32-1-066.7%0.172.83
Will ReichardKMIN30-3-00%-1.171.83
Brandon McManusKLA21-1-050%0.52.5
Cairo SantosKCHI22-0-0100%1.52
Cam LittleKJAX22-0-0100%22.5
Chase McLaughlinKTB21-1-050%1.51.5
Dominic ZvadaKNYG22-0-0100%1.51.5
Drew StevensKWAS21-1-050%02
Eddy PineiroKSF21-1-050%0.53
Harrison ButkerKKC21-1-050%01.5
Jake ElliottKPHI21-1-050%0.51.5
Jake MoodyKATL20-2-00%-0.51.5
Jason MyersKSEA20-2-00%-1.52.5
Matt GayKLV21-1-050%01.5
Wil LutzKDEN22-0-0100%0.52
Daniel CarlsonK—10-1-00%-0.51.5
Tyler LoopKBAL10-1-00%-1.52.5
Zane GonzalezKMIA11-0-0100%2.51.5
All players, Extra points——7938-41-048.1%0.152.04

Data as of 2026-11-17 01:15 UTCSource: Kelly's consensus closing line: each book's last price before the start, margin removed, then averaged; nflverse data (CC BY 4.0)Seasons 2026, regular season; each player-game graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart.Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples and left out of the ranks.A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.