Skip to content
Kelly
Join the waitlist

NFL player prop history

Across 5,785 graded player props in the 2026 season, overs hit 30.7% of decided games against each game's own closing line (1770-3998-17 over-under-push). Quarterback passing yards went over 52.2% of the time (60-55-0).

By market (35)

Each player-game is graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart. Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples. A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.

Showing (35) of (35) · Totals · Compared with every market with 10+ decided games (28)

MarketPositionGradedO-U-POver %Avg vs closeAvg closePlayers
Quarterbacks
Passing yardsQuarterbacks11560-55-052.2%-0.09227.4342
Passing TDsQuarterbacks11649-67-042.2%0.041.4142
Rushing yardsQuarterbacks11447-67-041.2%0.5913.0142
Anytime TDQuarterbacks11618-98-015.5%-0.340.542
Pass attemptsQuarterbacks11452-62-045.6%-1.7732.2842
CompletionsQuarterbacks11449-65-043%-1.0520.6542
Interceptions thrownQuarterbacks11464-50-056.1%0.260.542
Pass + rush yardsQuarterbacks6835-33-051.5%2.46243.1336
Rush attemptsQuarterbacks4411-33-025%-1.024.6121
TouchdownsQuarterbacks1140-114-00%-1.581.7542
Running backs
Rushing yardsRunning backs227110-117-048.5%5.440.4480
Receiving yardsRunning backs17986-93-048%6.1713.9266
ReceptionsRunning backs17583-92-047.4%0.172.2963
Anytime TDRunning backs33388-245-026.4%-0.240.5121
Rush attemptsRunning backs15673-83-046.8%0.1712.7962
Rush + receiving yardsRunning backs16182-79-050.9%5.2165.9562
TouchdownsRunning backs3277-320-02.1%-1.61.94121
Wide receivers
Rushing yardsWide receivers72-5-028.6%10.213.56
Receiving yardsWide receivers346170-176-049.1%5.5138.02129
ReceptionsWide receivers351168-183-047.9%-0.013.27131
Anytime TDWide receivers51897-421-018.7%-0.310.5185
Rush + receiving yardsWide receivers72-5-028.6%4.7963.646
TouchdownsWide receivers5084-504-00.8%-1.621.83183
Tight ends
Receiving yardsTight ends17790-87-050.8%4.6827.9661
ReceptionsTight ends17975-104-041.9%-0.012.9362
Anytime TDTight ends28446-238-016.2%-0.340.5105
TouchdownsTight ends2794-275-01.4%-1.621.8105
Kickers
Field goalsKickers10058-42-058%0.291.533
Extra pointsKickers7938-41-048.1%0.152.0432
Defense
Receiving yardsDefense31-2-033.3%-4.839.831
ReceptionsDefense31-2-033.3%-0.171.171
Anytime TDDefense30-3-00%-0.50.51
TouchdownsDefense30-3-00%-1.831.831
SacksDefense349100-232-1730.1%-0.110.5155
Other
SacksOther20-2-00%-0.50.51
All markets—5,7851770-3998-1730.7%0.6217.11643

Data as of 2026-11-17 01:15 UTCSource: Kelly's consensus closing line: each book's last price before the start, margin removed, then averaged; nflverse data (CC BY 4.0)Seasons 2026, regular season; each player-game graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart.Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples and left out of the ranks.A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.