Skip to content
Kelly
Join the waitlist

NFL player prop history by player

Anytime TD props in the 2026 season: overs hit 19.9% of decided games against each game's own closing line (249-1005-0 over-under-push, 454 players).

Anytime TD by player (454)

Each player-game is graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart. Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples. A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.

Showing (200) of (454) · Totals · Sorted by Graded, high to low · Compared with every player with 10+ decided games (0)

PlayerPosTeamGradedO-U-POver %Avg vs closeAvg close
AJ BarnerTESEA41-3-025%-0.250.5
Aaron JonesRBMIN41-3-025%-0.250.5
Adonai MitchellWRNYJ41-3-025%-0.250.5
Amon-Ra St. BrownWRDET41-3-025%-0.250.5
Andrew ArmstrongWRKC41-3-025%-0.250.5
Anthony Tyus IIIRBCAR41-3-025%-0.250.5
Antonio WilliamsWRWAS41-3-025%-0.250.5
Ashton DulinWRIND41-3-025%-0.250.5
Ashton JeantyRBLV41-3-025%-0.250.5
Austin EkelerRBWAS40-4-00%-0.50.5
Bijan RobinsonRBATL42-2-050%00.5
Blake CorumRBLA44-0-0100%0.50.5
Bo MeltonWRGB40-4-00%-0.50.5
Braelon AllenRBNYJ41-3-025%-0.250.5
Brevyn Spann-FordTEDAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Brock BowersTELV42-2-050%00.5
Brock PurdyQBSF41-3-025%-0.250.5
Bryce YoungQBCAR40-4-00%-0.50.5
Brycen TremayneWRCAR40-4-00%-0.50.5
Caleb DouglasWRMIA41-3-025%-0.250.5
CeeDee LambWRDAL43-1-075%0.250.5
Charlie WoernerTEATL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Chase BrownRBCIN41-3-025%-0.250.5
Chig OkonkwoTEWAS40-4-00%-0.50.5
Christian McCaffreyRBSF44-0-0100%0.50.5
Christian WatsonWRGB41-3-025%-0.250.5
Chuba HubbardRBCAR42-2-050%00.5
Cooper KuppWRSEA42-2-050%00.5
Corey KinerRBNE41-3-025%-0.250.5
Cyrus AllenWRKC41-3-025%-0.250.5
Dak PrescottQBDAL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Daniel JonesQBIND40-4-00%-0.50.5
Darren WallerTECAR42-2-050%00.5
DeAndre CarterWRDET40-4-00%-0.50.5
DeMario DouglasWRNE41-3-025%-0.250.5
DeeJay DallasRBMIN40-4-00%-0.50.5
Deion BurksWRIND40-4-00%-0.50.5
Denzel BostonWRCLE40-4-00%-0.50.5
Derrick HenryRBBAL42-2-050%00.5
Devin DuvernayWRARI40-4-00%-0.50.5
Dohnte MeyersWRCIN41-3-025%-0.250.5
Drake LondonWRATL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Drake MayeQBNE42-2-050%00.5
Dylan LaubeRBLV40-4-00%-0.50.5
Dylan SampsonRBCLE40-4-00%-0.50.5
Efton Chism IIIWRNE41-3-025%-0.250.5
Eli RaridonTENE41-3-025%-0.250.5
Emmett JohnsonRBKC43-1-075%0.250.5
Geno SmithQBNYJ40-4-00%-0.50.5
George KittleTESF41-3-025%-0.250.5
Greg DulcichTEMIA40-4-00%-0.50.5
Harold Fannin Jr.TECLE41-3-025%-0.250.5
Hunter HenryTENE40-4-00%-0.50.5
Isaiah DavisRBNYJ40-4-00%-0.50.5
Isaiah WilliamsWRNYJ41-3-025%-0.250.5
J. Michael SturdivantWRGB41-3-025%-0.250.5
Ja'Kobi LaneWRBAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Ja'Marr ChaseWRCIN43-1-075%0.250.5
Jacob CowingWRSF40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jahan DotsonWRATL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jahmyr GibbsRBDET43-1-075%0.250.5
Jalen CokerWRCAR41-3-025%-0.250.5
Jalen NailorWRLV41-3-025%-0.250.5
Jalen RoyalsWRKC40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jameson WilliamsWRDET42-2-050%00.5
Jared GoffQBDET40-4-00%-0.50.5
Javonte WilliamsRBDAL42-2-050%00.5
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWRSEA43-1-075%0.250.5
Jayden DanielsQBWAS40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jerry JeudyWRCLE40-4-00%-0.50.5
Joe BurrowQBCIN42-2-050%00.5
John Metchie IIIWRCAR40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jonathan TaylorRBIND41-3-025%-0.250.5
Jordan LoveQBGB41-3-025%-0.250.5
Jordan MasonRBMIN40-4-00%-0.50.5
Jordan WatkinsWRSF41-3-025%-0.250.5
Josh CuevasTEBAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Josh DownsWRKC42-2-050%00.5
Justice HillRBBAL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Justin JeffersonWRMIN41-3-025%-0.250.5
KC ConcepcionWRCLE42-2-050%00.5
Kaelon BlackRBSF42-2-050%00.5
Keenan AllenWRSF40-4-00%-0.50.5
Kenyon SadiqTENYJ40-4-00%-0.50.5
Kevin Coleman Jr.WRMIA41-3-025%-0.250.5
Khalil HerbertRBATL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Kirk CousinsQBMIN42-2-050%00.5
Konata MumpfieldWRLA40-4-00%-0.50.5
Kyle PittsTEATL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Kyle WilliamsWRNE41-3-025%-0.250.5
Kyren WilliamsRBLA42-2-050%00.5
LaJohntay WesterWRBAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Laquon TreadwellWRIND41-3-025%-0.250.5
Luke McCaffreyWRWAS40-4-00%-0.50.5
Malachi CorleyWRCLE40-4-00%-0.50.5
Malik WashingtonWRMIA41-3-025%-0.250.5
Mark AndrewsTEBAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Mason TaylorTENYJ41-3-025%-0.250.5
Matthew GoldenWRGB42-2-050%00.5
Matthew StaffordQBLA40-4-00%-0.50.5
Michael MayerTELV40-4-00%-0.50.5
Michael Penix Jr.QBATL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Mike GesickiTECIN42-2-050%00.5
Mike Washington Jr.RBLV40-4-00%-0.50.5
Mitchell EvansTECAR40-4-00%-0.50.5
Myles PriceWRMIN41-3-025%-0.250.5
Noah GrayTEKC41-3-025%-0.250.5
Ollie Gordon IIRBMIA41-3-025%-0.250.5
Patrick MahomesQBKC40-4-00%-0.50.5
Quinshon JudkinsRBCLE42-2-050%00.5
Rachaad WhiteRBWAS42-2-050%00.5
Rashod BatemanWRBAL40-4-00%-0.50.5
Rhamondre StevensonRBNE42-2-050%00.5
Ryan FlournoyWRDAL42-2-050%00.5
Sam LaPortaTEDET40-4-00%-0.50.5
Samaje PerineRBCIN42-2-050%00.5
Savion WilliamsWRGB41-3-025%-0.250.5
Seth McGowanRBIND42-2-050%00.5
Seydou TraoreTEMIA40-4-00%-0.50.5
Sione VakiRBDET40-4-00%-0.50.5
Stefon DiggsWRWAS43-1-075%0.250.5
Tahj BrooksRBCIN40-4-00%-0.50.5
Tee HigginsWRCIN43-1-075%0.250.5
Tetairoa McMillanWRCAR41-3-025%-0.250.5
Tommy TrembleTECAR41-3-025%-0.250.5
Travis KelceTEKC41-3-025%-0.250.5
Tre TuckerWRLV41-3-025%-0.250.5
Trevor EtienneRBCAR40-4-00%-0.50.5
Trey McBrideTEARI42-2-050%00.5
Tucker KraftTEGB42-2-050%00.5
Tyler AllgeierRBARI41-3-025%-0.250.5
Tyler HigbeeTELA41-3-025%-0.250.5
Xavier WorthyWRKC40-4-00%-0.50.5
Zay FlowersWRBAL41-3-025%-0.250.5
Aaron RodgersQBPIT30-3-00%-0.50.5
Adam PrenticeRBDEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Adam TrautmanTEDEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Alvin KamaraRBNO31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Andrew BeckRBNYJ30-3-00%-0.50.5
Austin HooperTEATL30-3-00%-0.50.5
Baker MayfieldQBTB30-3-00%-0.50.5
Bam KnightRBARI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Barion BrownWRNO30-3-00%-0.50.5
Ben YurosekTEMIN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Bhayshul TutenRBJAX33-0-0100%0.50.5
Blake WhiteheartTECLE30-3-00%-0.50.5
Bo NixQBDEN31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Brandin CooksWRSF30-3-00%-0.50.5
Brenton StrangeTEJAX31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Bryce LanceWRNO30-3-00%-0.50.5
Bucky IrvingRBTB33-0-0100%0.50.5
C.J. StroudQBHOU30-3-00%-0.50.5
Caleb WilliamsQBCHI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Cam WardQBTEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Charlie JonesWRNYG30-3-00%-0.50.5
Charlie KolarTELAC30-3-00%-0.50.5
Chimere DikeWRTEN31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Chris BellWRMIA30-3-00%-0.50.5
Chris BlairWRATL30-3-00%-0.50.5
Chris Godwin Jr.WRTB30-3-00%-0.50.5
Chris OlaveWRNO30-3-00%-0.50.5
Chris Rodriguez Jr.RBJAX32-1-066.7%0.170.5
Colby ParkinsonTELA30-3-00%-0.50.5
Coleman OwenWR—30-3-00%-0.50.5
Colson YankoffTEWAS30-3-00%-0.50.5
Colston LovelandTECHI31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Connor HeywardRBLV30-3-00%-0.50.5
Courtland SuttonWRDEN31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
D'Andre SwiftRBCHI32-1-066.7%0.170.5
DJ MooreWRBUF32-1-066.7%0.170.5
DK MetcalfWRPIT31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Dallas GoedertTEPHI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Dalton KincaidTEBUF31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Dalton SchultzTEHOU31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Daniel BellingerTETEN31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Dareke YoungWRLV30-3-00%-0.50.5
Darius CooperWRPHI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Darnell MooneyWRNYG30-3-00%-0.50.5
Darnell WashingtonTEPIT31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
David MooreWRCAR30-3-00%-0.50.5
Davis AllenTELA32-1-066.7%0.170.5
Dawson KnoxTEBUF30-3-00%-0.50.5
Derius DavisWRLAC31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Deshaun WatsonQBCLE32-1-066.7%0.170.5
Devaughn VeleWRNO31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Devin SingletaryRBNYG31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Eli StowersTEPHI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Elic AyomanorWRTEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Elijah HigginsTEARI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Elijah MitchellRBPHI30-3-00%-0.50.5
Evan EngramTEDEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Garrett WilsonWRNYJ30-3-00%-0.50.5
George HolaniRBSEA30-3-00%-0.50.5
George PickensWRDAL32-1-066.7%0.170.5
Germie BernardWRPIT30-3-00%-0.50.5
Greg DortchWRBUF30-3-00%-0.50.5
Gunnar HelmTETEN30-3-00%-0.50.5
Hunter LuepkeRBDAL30-3-00%-0.50.5
Isaac TeSlaaWRDET31-2-033.3%-0.170.5
Isaiah BondWRCLE30-3-00%-0.50.5
All players, Anytime TD——1,254249-1005-019.9%-0.30.5

Data as of 2026-11-17 01:15 UTCSource: Kelly's consensus closing line: each book's last price before the start, margin removed, then averaged; nflverse data (CC BY 4.0)Seasons 2026, regular season; each player-game graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart.Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples and left out of the ranks.A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.