Skip to content
Kelly
Join the waitlist

NFL player prop history by player

Pass + rush yards props in the 2026 season: overs hit 51.5% of decided games against each game's own closing line (35-33-0 over-under-push, 36 players).

Pass + rush yards by player (36)

Each player-game is graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart. Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples. A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.

Showing (36) of (36) · Totals · Sorted by Graded, high to low · Compared with every player with 10+ decided games (0)

PlayerPosTeamGradedO-U-POver %Avg vs closeAvg close
Bryce YoungQBCAR41-3-025%-41.5259.25
Caleb WilliamsQBCHI32-1-066.7%26.5263.17
Cam WardQBTEN32-1-066.7%62.5204.5
Daniel JonesQBIND30-3-00%-70.17199.83
Deshaun WatsonQBCLE33-0-0100%100.17237.83
Joe BurrowQBCIN33-0-0100%112.17285.5
Justin HerbertQBLAC31-2-033.3%-12.17229.5
Trevor LawrenceQBJAX31-2-033.3%26.17253.83
Tyler ShoughQBNO32-1-066.7%18.5252.5
Aaron RodgersQBPIT20-2-00%-59239
Brock PurdyQBSF22-0-0100%76.5275
C.J. StroudQBHOU21-1-050%59258.5
Dak PrescottQBDAL21-1-050%0282.5
Drake MayeQBNE21-1-050%-84.5287.5
Geno SmithQBNYJ21-1-050%-15.5233
J.J. McCarthyQBNYG22-0-0100%64226
Jacoby BrissettQBBAL21-1-050%-11245
Jordan LoveQBGB21-1-050%-11.5265.5
Josh AllenQBBUF20-2-00%-42.5267.5
Malik WillisQBMIA21-1-050%-52226
Michael Penix Jr.QBATL21-1-050%32231.5
Patrick MahomesQBKC21-1-050%47.5259
Baker MayfieldQBTB10-1-00%-170.5235.5
Bo NixQBDEN11-0-0100%8.5230.5
Carson BeckQBARI10-1-00%-78.5187.5
Carson WentzQBMIN10-1-00%-146.5227.5
Drew LockQBSEA11-0-0100%50.5209.5
Fernando MendozaQBLV10-1-00%-36.5201.5
Gardner MinshewQBARI10-1-00%-35.5205.5
Jared GoffQBDET11-0-0100%31.5274.5
Jayden DanielsQBWAS11-0-0100%35.5241.5
Kirk CousinsQBMIN10-1-00%-15.5233.5
Kyle McCordQBMIA11-0-0100%42.5170.5
Lamar JacksonQBBAL10-1-00%-268.5268.5
Matthew StaffordQBLA11-0-0100%35.5211.5
Tyler HuntleyQBBAL11-0-0100%83.5226.5
All players, Pass + rush yards——6835-33-051.5%2.46243.13

Data as of 2026-11-17 01:15 UTCSource: Kelly's consensus closing line: each book's last price before the start, margin removed, then averaged; nflverse data (CC BY 4.0)Seasons 2026, regular season; each player-game graded against that game's own closing line (Kelly's consensus before the start), main lines only, pushes counted apart.Rates under 10 decided games are marked as small samples and left out of the ranks.A prop's history is a count of past games against each game's own closing line: never an edge, a fair price or a pick.